After vowing for weeks to deliver a fully-costed platform, Ontario's Progressive Conservatives yesterday quietly released a compilation of their campaign promises without saying how they would pay for them.
The updated “Plan for the People,” posted on the party's website, lays out how much each initiative is expected to cost but not where the money will come from.
Nor does it explain the billions in so-called “efficiencies” PC leader Doug Ford has promised to find.
Ford did not speak about the online document but his spokeswoman said it was the party's final plan.
“We do not know the state of Ontario's finances and anyone who tells you they do is lying to you,” said Melissa Lantsman, alluding to the provincial auditor general's finding that the governing Liberals' deficit projections are understated by billions.
Lantsman said the Tories would not balance the budget in the first or second year of their term, but were committed to getting the books back in the black as quickly as possible.
Ford faced increasing criticism for not releasing a full platform earlier in the campaign, with NDP leader Andrea Horwath and Liberal Premier Kathleen Wynne deeming it disrespectful to voters.
Both Horwath and Wynne heaped scorn on the notion that Ford had released a full plan yesterday.
“Look, this is not a fully-costed plan, it's not coherent,” Wynne said at a stop in Markham, Ont., where she pushed her government's transit record.
“All of the things that Doug Ford has said would add up to a $40-billion hole and they have no idea how they would find that.”
Horwath was equally jaundiced, saying it wasn't good enough for Ford to write a “list of things he might do and put it on the internet.”
People should know what Ford's plans are, what he's going to cut, and what services might be at risk, the NDP leader said.
“His list of things-to-do that he put on his website is not going to help people to decide which way to vote and what's their best interest in this campaign,” Horwath stressed.
“What's worrisome is we have a leader who's trying to take the chair of the premier in this province and he's not being honest with people.”
The Tories began the campaign with a significant lead only to find themselves now battling the NDP for first place in the polls, which also show the Liberals falling further behind both.
With the election just a week away, Wynne travelled to the heart of her NDP rival's riding yesterday to portray herself as the only seasoned stateswoman in the campaign capable of rising above the ideological fray.
At a stop in Hamilton outside a Stelco steel plant, she attacked both Horwath and Ford as unyielding ideologues without the experience to fend off the threat of American steel tariffs.
“On the one end of the spectrum, you have Doug Ford—he's expressed his admiration for [U.S. President] Donald Trump, despite the chaos, the uncertainty that the Trump administration has caused Ontario,” Wynne noted.
“On the other extreme, you have the NDP, who have historically campaigned against free-trade agreements—I would suggest a rigid and impractical position.”
The U.S. has exempted Canadian steel and aluminum from new tariffs on an interim basis.
The exemption is due to expire tomorrow.
While the federal government under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has done much of the heavy lifting to protect the industry in Canada, Wynne played up her own efforts.
“Over the past year, I have met with 37 governors, I have met with senators, I've met with congresspeople, I've met with senior members of the U.S. administration, all in an attempt to make it clear what our integrated relationship means to workers on both sides of the border,” said Wynne, who has been trailing behind her rivals in recent polls.
“We were assertive, we were steadfast in our effort to make Ontario's case to those decision-makers,” she noted.
“That threat of U.S. protectionism is not going to scare us off.”
Wynne said Ontario has developed one of the strongest economies in North America under a Liberal government that worked with employees, business leaders, and political leaders on both sides of the Canada-U.S. border.
Voters have a choice between her and her two inexperienced rivals, she added.
“They're going to be choosing a person to lead them who will be in some very tricky, very delicate negotiations with U.S. officials,” Wynne said.
“That's the reality of the role premier [and] we cannot let ideology get in our way.”