OTTAWA—The federal Liberals want to widen the reach of the country's job-training programs after senior officials heard warnings that Canada has been spending about half what comparable countries do on efforts to keep their workers employable.
A presentation to the committee of deputy ministers, delivered in January, 2018, warned the country will be less able to adapt to workforce shifts without a boost in spending.
The Canadian Press obtained documents under the federal access-to-information law at a time when the Liberals publicly have talked about using the 2019 budget—the last before next fall's federal election—to focus on skills training.
According to the presentation, Canada spent about 0.1 percent of its economic output on training programs for workers displaced by computers and other shifts in the economy.
The average in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, a group of the world's developed countries, was 0.2 percent in 2015.
Denmark spent 0.6 percent, with Finland, Austria, and France not far behind it.
Canada ranked ahead of only Poland, Australia, and Hungary in its share of workers in publicly-funded training programs.
Many times more people used such programs in Austria, Belgium, Finland, and Denmark (the countries at the top).
There also is a suggestion in the documents that skills-training programs need to be better tailored for workers at higher risk of being left behind, such as indigenous people, newcomers, and people with disabilities.
Past Liberal budgets have put billions into job-training programs, which largely are the domain of provincial governments, hoping to get more people into the labour force to reduce poverty and keep the economy growing.
Despite that, the 2018 presentation said Canada still lags.
In a year-end interview, Social Development minister Jean-Yves Duclos said the federal government needs to do more to help cash-strapped provinces pay for training programs and ensure better information-sharing between jurisdictions as technology kills some jobs and creates others.
“We need more money because there is the growing importance of training and retraining, but also we need to be better able to share in Canada what is done in particular regions,” Duclos noted.
Canadian economic growth appears to be slowing down after a hot 2017.
Economic growth could hover between 1.5 percent and two percent over the next few decades, according to projections from the Finance Department and parliamentary budget watchdog, as Canada's workforce ages and shrinks.
More people likely will retire from the workforce than enter it.
The shift will increase the “importance of technological advances to Canada's economic future,” said the January presentation to the government's top civil servants.
Those technological advances are expected to make some jobs obsolete, largely as a result of automation.
The percentage of Canadian workers at high risk of being affected by automation over the next two decades varies from 42 percent to nine percent, depending on the study.
And federal officials aren't sure if the disruption in the labour force will create enough jobs to replace the ones that likely are to be lost, which is why the Liberals are taking a close look at what can be done to expand training programs.
“Retraining and training will be increasingly important,” Duclos stressed.
“We need to work with partners—provinces and territories—but given that the challenges faced by provinces and territories are in many cases common to all of these provinces and territories, there is a federal role that needs to be addressed,” he added.
Conservative critic Karen Vecchio said the work with provinces and territories should include a view of what's happening in the school system so students graduate with the skills necessary to take them through multiple jobs.
But retraining might not be for everyone.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said in a separate interview with The Canadian Press that the Liberals also are looking at ways to bridge the gap between work and retirement for older workers who likely won't be able to become computer programmers overnight.
“That's something we're going to have to look at and we are looking at—supports for people who are not going to retrain,” he noted.