You are here

Plant-based burgers vs. beef

Category: 

NEW YORK—If you want to skip meat, a new era of options is here.

Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods are among the companies racing to tap into the massive U.S. market of meat eaters by more closely mimicking the taste of beef than vegetarian patties of the past.

Others are working to grow meat in labs.

So are the plant-based patties better for you or for the planet?

Here's what you might want to know before taking a bite:

ARE THEY HEALTHIER?

As with many questions about diet, it depends.

For better or worse, patties from Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods can be nutritionally similar to beef.

Beyond Meat's four-ounce patty is listed at 270 calories, while Impossible Foods' is listed at 240 calories.

Ground beef's nutritional profile can range, but a similarly sized patty with 80 percent lean meat has around 290 calories.

Protein content is about the same, while other nutrients vary.

Some may like that the plant-based patties have fibre, but dislike that they're higher in sodium.

For overall diet, what matters more might be how the patties are served, whether it's at Burger King, White Castle or elsewhere.

At Umami Burger in New York, for example, a burger with two Impossible patties, cheese and fixings tops 1,000 calories.

Few would call it healthy, especially if served with fries and a soda.

“People are going to be fooling themselves into thinking these are not just better, but healthy,” said Yoni Freedhoff, an obesity expert at the University of Ottawa.

People also may not realize the saturated fat content can be similar to beef burgers, he said.

WHAT'S IN THEM?

Beyond Meat's ingredients include pea protein and canola oil. Impossible Food's patties have soy protein and coconut oil.

Impossible says its patties have a flavour and hue similar to beef partly because of soy leghemoglobin, a protein the company makes by genetically modifying yeast.

The meat industry, meanwhile, is appealing to people who prefer simpler ingredient lists.

“A beef patty is one natural ingredient: beef,” says the North American Meat Institute, which represents meat makers.

HOW DO THEY TASTE?

Taste is subjective, but reviews generally say Beyond Meat and Impossible burgers taste similar to meat.

Christian Acosta, who works in New York, said he's had the Impossible burger several times and can't tell the difference.

Unlike with a steak, any discrepancies in taste between beef and the plant-based burgers may be masked by buns, cheese and toppings.

ARE THEY BETTER

FOR THE EARTH?

Experts say reducing overall red meat consumption would be better for the planet.

Beef is considered taxing on the environment because of the resources it takes to grow crops to feed cows.

Cows also produce the greenhouse gas methane, mostly through burps.

Christopher Field, who is at the Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment and who knows the founder of Impossible Foods, noted people don't have to give up meat entirely to make a difference, and that pork and chicken have much smaller environmental footprints than beef.

Free story: 
Twitter icon
Facebook icon
Google icon
LinkedIn icon
Pinterest icon
Reddit icon
e-mail icon